Appendix Removal Linked to Lower Future Parkinson's Risk

Sue Hughes

Two new epidemiologic studies have suggested an important role for the appendix in the origin of Parkinson's disease.

One large study, which involved the whole population of Sweden and had a 50-year follow-up, found that individuals whose appendix had been removed in early life had a 20% lower risk of developing Parkinson's disease later in life.

The second study, from the United States, found that for Parkinson's disease patients whose appendix had been removed earlier in life, the age at disease onset was later than for those who had not undergone an appendectomy.

Both studies were published online October 31 in one article in Science Translational Medicine.

"Overall, our research shows the appendix to be a tissue site that plays a key role in the initiation of Parkinson's disease, and further raises interest in the potential of gastrointestinal-based therapies for the treatment and prevention of Parkinson's disease," senior author Viviane Labrie, PhD, Van Andel Research Institute, Grand Rapids, Michigan, stated.

Labrie was speaking at a news conference organized by the American Association for the Advancement of Science, publisher of Science Translational Medicine. The news conference featured several authors of the article, all from the Van Andel Research Institute.

The researchers also found a high level of alpha-synuclein clumps in appendix tissue both from patients with Parkinson's and healthy individuals. Alpha-synuclein is known to be a factor in the pathology of Parkinson's disease in the brain.

"We are not advocating removing the appendix as a preventative treatment for Parkinson's, and we are not saying that if you have had an appendectomy, you will not get Parkinson's," Labrie said. "But what we can say is that the appendix is a potential reservoir for the clumped form of alpha-synuclein that is associated with Parkinson's disease in the brain. While this clumped alpha-synuclein appears to be normal in the appendix, it is pathogenic in the brain, so location is everything.

"These alpha-synuclein clumps are present in the appendix in almost everyone, but we think that in Parkinson's patients, these clumps escape via the vagal nerve to the brain," she said. Alternatively, inflammation of the gastrointestinal (GI) tract that involves the appendix may play a role, she added.

"Our findings suggest that the appendix is one possible initiation site for Parkinson's disease. But removing the appendix does not completely eliminate the disease, so it likely that there are other key sites of origin too," Labrie said. "Rather than advocating universal appendectomy, it would therefore be better to try and control the excessive formation of alpha-synuclein clumps in the GI tract altogether and also to try and prevent their escape from the GI tract to the brain."

Nonmotor Symptoms

Labrie explained that Parkinson's disease has been regarded as a movement disorder driven by loss of dopaminergic neurons in the substantia nigra region of the brain. However, in the past decade, it has become evident that the disease is not just a motor disorder but also encompasses a whole range of nonmotor symptoms, including GI symptoms that often occur years or even decades before the motor symptoms develop.

"More clinical attention is now focused on the GI tract, not only in terms of symptoms but also as a possible site where Parkinson's disease may begin," she added.

The hallmark pathology of Parkinson's disease is the appearance of Lewy bodies — clumps of alpha-synuclein — in the brain. There is evidence that in patients with Parkinson's disease, clumps of alpha-synuclein are also present in the GI tract, sometimes many years before the onset of motor symptoms, Labrie noted.

"Also, it looks like alpha-synuclein does not like to stay put," she said. "It can move from neurone to neurone and can travel up nerves that link the gut to the brain, where it causes neurotoxic effects. One of the first areas of the brain in which these clumps of alpha-synuclein are seen in Parkinson's patients is the terminal of the vagal nerve, which links the gut to the brain, and the disease advances and progresses from there."

Labrie said she and her colleagues wanted to study specific areas of gut that may be involved in Parkinson's and focused on the appendix, because the appendix plays an immunomodulatory role in the body.

"It is responsible for sampling and modulating pathogens and raising an immune response," she noted. "In addition, the gut microbiome has been linked to Parkinson's disease, and the appendix is a storage area for gut bacteria and can affect the regulation of bacteria in the GI tract. We therefore conducted the current studies examining the effects of removing the appendix on Parkinson's disease risk."

20% Risk Reduction

The researchers first analyzed data from the Swedish National Patient Registry, which documents hospitalizations and surgeries for the whole Swedish population.

They identified all individuals in Sweden who had had their appendix removed since 1964. Each of these patients was matched to two control persons from the general population who had not undergone an appendectomy. The researchers analyzed data from a total of 1.7 million individuals. Follow-up data were available for up to 52 years.

Results showed that the risk of developing Parkinson's disease was reduced by almost 20% among people who had had their appendix removed.

The incidence of Parkinson's disease was 1.60 per 100,000 person-years among individuals who had undergone an appendectomy, compared to 1.98 for control persons, representing a risk reduction of 19.3% (95% confidence interval, 10.4% - 27.2%).

The risk reduction was even greater (around 25%) in people who lived in rural areas, indicating that environmental factors may also be involved.

In the Swedish study, among those who developed Parkinson's disease, the age of diagnosis was on average 1.6 years later in individuals who had undergone an appendectomy 20 or more years earlier than in persons who had not undergone an appendectomy.

Delay in Disease Onset

From the second dataset — the US Parkinson's Progression Markers Initiative — the researchers analyzed data on 849 patients with Parkinson's disease and found that 6.5% had undergone an appendectomy earlier in life.

In those who had undergone an appendectomy, the age of onset of Parkinson's disease was on average 3.6 years later than in those patients who had not had their appendix removed.

The researchers examined appendix samples from 48 healthy individuals and found a "remarkable abundance" of the clumped form of alpha-synuclein in 46 of 48 samples.

"This is important, as previously, we thought these clumps of alpha-synuclein would occur only in Parkinson's patients. But our results show that in the appendix, they are equally abundant in healthy individuals," said coauthor Patrik Brundin, PhD. "Levels were also similar in normal and acutely and chronically inflamed appendix tissue and in younger and older people.

"It seems like the presence of alpha-synuclein aggregates in the nerve cells of the appendix is not a feature unique to Parkinson's disease, as it is found in almost all individuals. It is also not associated with ageing," Brundin added.

Truncated Form of Alpha-Synuclein

However, with further biochemical analysis, the researchers found that certain forms of alpha-synuclein were more common in the appendix of Parkinson's patients. In particular, there was a 4.5-fold increase of truncated alpha-synuclein, which is prone to extremely rapid clumping, the lead author of the article, Bryan Killinger, PhD, said.

"Our data suggest that there is a unique shortening of alpha-synuclein in the appendix, which accelerates its ability to form clumps and is a risk factor for Parkinson's disease," he stated. "Future research could focus on this truncated form of the protein."

Commenting on the study, Orla Smith, PhD, editor of Science Translational Medicine, said: "This paper presents clear evidence that pathogenic events take place in the GI tract and enteric nervous system.

"The authors show that the human appendix may be a reservoir for pathogenic forms of alpha-synuclein that are known to cause Parkinson's disease when mutated in the brain," she said.

"Science Translational Medicine is excited to publish this carefully executed study, which expands our understanding of the earliest stages of one of the most common and debilitating neurological diseases."

Sci Transl Med. Published online October 31. Full text

Categories: 

Comments

Interestingly olfactory sensation and taste also becomes less in early neurodegenerative diseases like Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s disease. The former is predominantly an alpha syn-nucleinopathy and the latter is a taupathy. 10-20% of these diseases are purely genetic.

I feel that Further research would likely tell us that neurodegenerative diseases are more genetic mutations leading to proteinopathies.

I believe that PD , as with all diseases and illnesses , is caused by too much animal protein .

As is appendicitis due to lack of fiber in meat based diets.

It would seem to me that it is critical to know how the diagnosis of PD was made.  Perhaps this is addressed in the on-line version. Some patents have had PD for decades before it is diagnosed and the comparability of the two groups (with or without appendectomy) in terms of age at diagnosis and diagnostic method used should be stated.   PD, as mentioned,contains many different "sub-groups" and at present no definitive diagnostic test .The relative proportions of  each group (e,g,. non-motor} in those withcould give valuable information.  I assume an analysis of this kind is underway.  Diagnosing PD manifested only as non-motor symptoms would be difficult indeed - I suspect there is little information on this.

Although this was a clinical study, there were some appendices available for pathological studies.  What fraction were positive?  Did the authors attempt to determine whether the  alpha synuclein, was confined to nervous tissue in the appendices?  This may be difficult to determine in inflamed tissue, but many normal appendices are removed - e.g., those  in whom the diagnosis of appendicitis was wrong, or in those in whom the the organ was removed to prevent appendicitis in the future - the main operation being done for another reason?

I have no conflicts of interest.

Add new comment